JL: Today the notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian. I don't know if you've spoken to Elden Lawrence. He would tell you you're wrong if you believe that. I see in the Indian communities today that the youth are being persuaded or influenced to take up the traditional religion because they are being told that they can't be an Indian and a Christian at the same time, and that's wrong.
The notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian
The notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian
Mr. LaBatte reflects on how Dakota spirituality and Christianity are viewed by some Dakota today.
Audio Chapters
Chapter 1
Cite
John LaBatte. "The notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian." https://www3.mnhs.org/usdakotawar/stories/contributors/john-labatte/1073
Print This Page

Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at Copyright and Use Information.
Oral History- Interview | Narrator John LaBatte Interviewer Deborah Locke made in New Ulm, MN | Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Read or listen to entire Oral History
Citation: Minnesota Historical Society. U.S. - Dakota War of 1862. The notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian. May 23, 2025.

Other Stories by Narrator
- Take the politics out of it and deal with it from a historical aspect
- I believe that Little Crow was a reluctant leader
- The notion is that if you're Christian you can't be an Indian
- Some people call it a clash of cultures. I don't, that's too general
- I see errors in Minnesota Historical Society's signs and books
- Do you think they would have stopped to have trials?
- Education needs to tell the truth about what happened
- I believe in understanding on both sides
- Two of my grandfathers were sentenced to hang at Mankato
- Where did the Dakota Indian get their land?
- That whole process is very complicated
- They're still fighting the Dakota War among themselves